. Chapter, The History of the Thesis Quoted Literature Boon, T., 2001 ? Governing forestry by means of participation?!, COST E 19 meeting, working paper, p.17

G. Buttoud, 1999 ? Principles of participatory processes in public decision making Regional Forest Programmes: a Participatory Approach to Support Forest Based Regional Development, EFI Proceedings, (32), pp.11-28, 1999.

G. Buttoud, Negotiation methods to support participatory forestry planning Regional Forest Programmes: a Participatory Approach to Support Forest Based Regional Development, EFI Proceedings, (32), pp.29-45, 1999.

G. Buttoud, Developing partnership between forestry agencies and stakeholders: the mixed model as a strategic planning tool. in: Partnership in Forestry, Proceedings of Joint FAO/ECE/ILO Committee on Forest Policy, pp.3-6, 2002.

G. Buttoud and J. M. Samyn, 1999 -Politique et planification forestière; guide pour la formulation et l'évaluation

G. Buttoud and I. Yunusova, A ???mixed model??? for the formulation of a multipurpose mountain forest policy., Forest Policy and Economics, vol.4, issue.2, pp.149-160
DOI : 10.1016/S1389-9341(02)00014-X

G. Buttoud and I. Yunusova, The mixed model for decision making as a conceptual framework for IMP formulation (eds) The formulation of integrated management plans (IMPs) for mountain forests, Proceedings of the international research course, pp.19-31, 2002.

G. Buttoud and I. Yunusova, 2003b -Negotiation concepts, methods and procedures for IMP formulation (eds) The formulation of integrated management plans (IMPs) for mountain forests, Proceedings of the international research course, pp.135-149, 2002.

D. B. Dovie, 2003 -Whose involvement? -can hierarchical valuation scheme intercede for participatory methods for evaluating secondary forest resource use? Forest Policy and, Economics, issue.5, pp.265-283

A. Finger-stich, 2003 -Social factors enabling local peoples' participation in integrated management planning in the context of forested mountain territories (eds) The formulation of integrated management plans (IMPs) for mountain forests, Proceedings of the international research course, pp.97-119, 2002.

F. Fischer and J. Forester, 1993 -The argumentative turn in policy analysis and planning

J. Forester, Beyond Dialogue to Transformative Learning: How Deliberative Rituals Encourage Political Judgment in Community Planning Processes, Democratic Dialogues: Theories and Practices, Poznan studies in the philosophy of the sciences and the humanities, 1996.
DOI : 10.1007/978-94-011-5462-8_7

I. Kouplevatskaya-yunusova, Spirals of forest policy development or transformation of participation in an iterative process ? the case of Kyrgyzstan (eds) The evaluation of forest policies and programmes, pp.103-115, 2004.

. Kyrgyz-republic and . Government, 1999 -National Forest Policy of Kyrgyzstan. Kyrgyz State Forest Service

. Kyrgyz-republic and . Government, 2004 -Concept of forestry sector development in Kyrgyz Republic. Intercooperation ? Kyrgyz State Forest Service

. Kyrgyz-republic and . Government, 2006 -National Action Plan 2006-2010. State Agency on Environment Protection and Foretsry ? Intercooperation ? SDC

D. Pettenella and L. Secco, 2004 -New trends in Italian forest policies: a shift of the focus from mountains to plains The evaluation of forest policies and programmes, pp.55-64

D. Pettenella, G. Santi, A. Erkkilä, R. Heinonen, G. Oesten et al., 2005 -Illegal logging and corporate social responsibility: the Italian experience European forests and beyond, an ethical discourse, pp.259-270

I. Yunusova, The Kyrgyz forestry concept: a participatory process for forest policy formulation in Kyrgyzstan (eds) Regional Forestry Programmes: a Participatory Approach to Support Forest Based Regional Development, pp.93-101, 1999.

I. Yunusova, Participation as a basis for the elaboration of forest policy: practical example from Kyrgyzstan. Presentation at the Community of Practice on Participation in NFP, 2002.

I. Yunusova, The national forest policy in Kyrgyzstan: 5 years on the road with participation (assessment of the stakeholders participation in the evaluation of forest policy), 2003.

I. Yunusova, 2004 ? Elaboration of the new forest policy, based on participation of stakeholders, Les Tokoi (Kyrgyz Forestry Journal), vol.28, pp.15-20

I. Yunusova, G. Buttoud, and A. Chingojoev, 2000 -Case study: Kyrgyz forestry concept: policy for a multipurpose management of mountain forests in Central Asia (eds) Forests in Sustainable Mountain Development: a State of Knowledge Report for, pp.411-413, 2000.

I. Yunusova, G. Buttoud, and E. Grisa, Reforming forest policy in Kyrgyzstan: impediments and success of the process in extreme ecological and unstable socio-economic environment, The Austrian Journal of Forest Science, vol.120, issue.1, pp.73-82, 2003.

I. Chapter, Participation as a constructed concept Quoted Literature Participation from evidence to construction

S. Andersen and K. Eliassen, 1993 -Making policy in Europe: the europification of national policy -making

F. Ankersmit, 2000 -Comments on Bevir's « The Logic of the History of Ideas ». Rethinking History, pp.321-332

P. Beers, Common ground, complex problems and decision making. Group decision and negotiation, pp.15-529, 2006.
DOI : 10.1007/s10726-006-9030-1

URL : http://dspace.ou.nl/bitstream/1820/2329/1/Common%20Ground%2c%20Complex%20Problems%20and%20Decision%20Making.pdf

M. Bevir, 1999 -The Logic of the History of Ideas

T. Beierle, 1999 -Using social goals to evaluate public participation in environmental decisions, Policy Studies Review, vol.16, pp.3-4

O. '. Brian and E. A. , Human values and their importance to the development of forestry policy in Britain: a literature review, Forestry, vol.76, issue.1, pp.3-17, 2003.
DOI : 10.1093/forestry/76.1.3

G. Buttoud, 1999 ? Principles of participatory processes in public decision making Regional Forest Programmes: A Participatory Approach to Support Forest Based Regional Development, EFI Proceedings, pp.11-28

G. Buttoud, Negotiation methods to support participatory forestry planning Regional Forest Programmes: A Participatory Approach to Support Forest Based Regional Development, EFI Proceedings, pp.29-45, 1999.

M. Côté and L. Bouthillier, Assessing the effect of public involvement process in forest management in Quebec, Forest Policy and Economics, issue.4, pp.213-225, 2002.

J. L. Creighton, 1992 -Involving Citizens in Community Decision Making: Program for Community Problem Solving, National League of Cities

D. Dovie, B. , and K. , 2003 -Whose involvement? -can hierarchical valuation scheme intercede for participatory methods for evaluating secondary forest resource use?, Forest Policy and Economics, issue.5, pp.265-283

F. Fischer and J. Forester, 1993 -The Argumentative Turn in Policy Analysis and Planning

J. Forester, Beyond dialogue to transformative learning: how deliberative rituals encourage political judgment in community planning process Democratic Dialogues: Theories and Practices, Poznan studies in the philosophy of the sciences and the humanities, 1996.

T. J. Foy, M. J. Pitcher, and C. B. Willis, Participatory development of forest policy: some practical lessons from recent South African Experience, Commonwealth Forestry Review, vol.77, issue.2, pp.100-106, 1998.

J. Friedman, Planning in the public domain: from knowledge to action, 1987.

P. Glueck, National Forest Programmes ? Significance of a Forest Policy Framework Formulation and Implementation of National Forest Programmes, International Experiences, Theoretocal Aspects, Proceedings of the nternational Seminar EFI Proceedings, pp.18-20, 1998.

J. Habermas, Communications and the evolution of society, 1979.

J. Habermas, 1991 -The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere: An Inquiry into a category of Bourgeois Society

H. Jenkins-smith and P. Sabatier, 1994 -Evaluating the Advocacy Coalition Framework, Journal of Public Policy, issue.14, pp.175-203

H. Kitschelt, Political Opportunity Structures and Political Protest: Anti-Nuclear Movements in Four Democracies, British Journal of Political Science, vol.16, issue.01, pp.57-85
DOI : 10.1017/S000712340000380X

F. Korten, Y. S. Robert, and . Jr, 1989 -Transforming a Bureaucracy: The Experience of the Philippine National Irrigation Administration

H. Kriesi, R. Koopmans, J. W. Duyvendak, and M. G. Giugni, 1995 -New social movements in Western Europe : a comparative analysis

F. Laird and N. , Participatory Analysis, Democracy, and Technological Decision Making, Science, Technology & Human Values, vol.18, issue.3, pp.341-361, 1993.
DOI : 10.1177/016224399301800305

W. Parsons, Public Policy: An Introduction to the theory and practice of policy analysis, 1995.

J. Richardson, 1982 -Policy Styles in Western Europe

J. Reitbergen-mccracken and D. Narayan, 1998 ? Participation and Social Assessment, Tools and Techniques

P. Sabatier and A. , Top-Down and Bottom-Up Approaches to Implementation Research: a Critical Analysis and Suggested Synthesis, Journal of Public Policy, vol.5, issue.01, pp.21-48, 1986.
DOI : 10.1016/0305-0483(80)90019-5

P. Sabatier and A. , An advocacy coalition framework of policy change and the role of policy-oriented learning therein, Policy Sciences, vol.16, issue.No. 1, pp.129-168, 1988.
DOI : 10.1007/BF00136406

D. W. Sewell and T. O-'riordan, 1976 -The culture of participation in environmental decision-making, Natural Resources Journal, issue.16, pp.1-21

M. Shannon, Moving from the limits and problems of rational planning toward a collaborative and participatory planning approach, Formulation and Implementation of National Forest Programmes. EFI Proceedings, pp.139-151, 1999.

M. Shannon, Understanding collaboration as deliberative communication, organisational form and emergent institution, National Forest Programmes in a European Context. EFI Proceedings, pp.7-25, 2002.

M. Shannon, -The use of participatory approaches, methods and techniques in the elaboration on Integrated Management Plans(eds) The formulation of integrated management plans (IMPs) for mountain forests, Proceedings of the international research course, pp.119-135, 2003.
URL : https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01005215

H. Schanz, 1997 -On the role of the state in German forestry: implications for forest policy and forest policy science, Review on Forest Policy Issues and Policy Processes. EFI Proceedings

H. Schanz, 1998 -Sustainable forest management as an expression of conflicting views of reality

P. Tabbush, Public money for public good? Public participation in forest planning, Forestry, vol.77, issue.2, pp.145-156, 2004.
DOI : 10.1093/forestry/77.2.145

T. Webler and S. Tuler, 2002 -Unlocking puzzle for public participation. Bulletin of science, technology & society, pp.179-189

W. Bank, 1991 -The Forest Sector. A World Bank Policy Paper

W. Bank, 1996 -The World Bank Participation Sourcebook. Mainstreaming Participatory Development Processes. The World Bank

F. Ankersmit, 2000 -Comments on Bevir's « The Logic of the History of Ideas ». Rethinking History, pp.321-332

S. Arnstein, A Ladder Of Citizen Participation, Journal of the American Institute of Planners, vol.35, issue.4, pp.216-224, 1969.
DOI : 10.1080/01944366908977225

P. Beers, J. Boshuizen, H. , P. , A. Kirscher et al., 2002 -Decision-support and complexity in decision making. Paper presented at the 5 th JURE conference, pp.19-23, 2002.

M. Bevir, 1999 -The Logic of the History of Ideas

T. Beierle, 1999 -Using social goals to evaluate public participation in environmental decisions, Policy Studies Review, vol.16, pp.3-4

O. Brian and E. A. , 2003 -Human values and their importance to the development of forestry policy in Britain: a literature review, Forestry, vol.1, issue.76, pp.3-17

G. Buttoud, 1999 ? Principles of participatory processes in public decision making, Regional Forest Programmes: A Participatory Approach to Support Forest Based Regional Development. EFI Proceedings, pp.11-28

M. Côté and L. Bouthillier, Assessing the effect of public involvement process in forest management in Quebec, Forest Policy and Economics, issue.4, pp.213-225, 2002.

T. J. Foy, M. J. Pitcher, and C. B. Willis, Participatory Development of forest policy: some practical lessons from recent South African Experience, Commonwealth Forestry Review, vol.77, issue.2, pp.100-106, 1998.

J. Habermas, Communications and the evolution of society, 1979.

J. Habermas, 1991 -The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere: An Inquiry into a category of Bourgeois Society

H. Kitschelt, Political Opportunity Structures and Political Protest: Anti-Nuclear Movements in Four Democracies, British Journal of Political Science, vol.16, issue.01, pp.57-85
DOI : 10.1017/S000712340000380X

F. Korten, Y. S. Robert, and . Jr, 1989 -Transforming a Bureaucracy: The Experience of the Philippine National Irrigation Administration

H. Kriesi, R. Koopmans, J. W. Duyvendak, and M. G. Et-giugni, 1995 -New social movements in Western Europe : a comparative analysis

F. Laird and N. , Participatory Analysis, Democracy, and Technological Decision Making, Science, Technology & Human Values, vol.18, issue.3, pp.341-361, 1993.
DOI : 10.1177/016224399301800305

W. Parsons, Public Policy: An Introduction to the Theory and Practice of Policy Analysis, 1995.

J. Richardson, 1982 -Policy Styles in Western Europe

J. Reitbergen-mccracken and D. Narayan, 1998 ? Participation and Social Assessment, Tools and Techniques

P. Sabatier and A. , Top-Down and Bottom-Up Approaches to Implementation Research: a Critical Analysis and Suggested Synthesis, Journal of Public Policy, vol.5, issue.01, pp.21-48
DOI : 10.1016/0305-0483(80)90019-5

P. Sabatier and A. , An advocacy coalition framework of policy change and the role of policy-oriented learning therein, Policy Sciences, vol.16, issue.No. 1, pp.129-168, 1988.
DOI : 10.1007/BF00136406

D. W. Sewell and T. O-'riordan, 1976 -The Culture of Participation in Environmental Decisionmaking, Natural Resources Journal, vol.16, pp.1-21

M. Shannon, Moving from the limits and problems of rational planning toward a collaborative and participatory planning approach, Formulation and Implementation of National Forest Programmes. EFI Proceedings n° 30, pp.139-151, 1999.

M. Shannon, 2002 -Understanding collaboration as deliberative communication, organisational form and emergent institution, Gislerund O., and Neven I., Edit: National Forest Programmes in a European Context. EFI Proceedings N 44, pp.7-25, 2002.

M. F. Shannon, G. Buttoud, and . Edit, -The use of participatory approaches, methods and techniques in the elaboration on Integrated Management Plans The formulation of integrated management plans (IMPs) for mountain forests, Proceedings of the international research course, pp.119-135, 2002.
URL : https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01005215

T. Webler and S. Tuler, 2002 -Unlocking puzzle for public participation. Bulletin of science, technology & society, pp.179-189

M. Appelstrand, Participation and societal values: the challenge for lawmakers and policy practitioners, Forest Policy and Economics, vol.4, issue.4, pp.281-290, 2002.
DOI : 10.1016/S1389-9341(02)00070-9

P. Beers, J. Boshuizen, H. , P. , A. Kirscher et al., 2002 -Decision-support and complexity in decision making. Paper presented at the 5 th, JURE conference, pp.19-23, 2002.

T. Boon, Governing forestry by means of participation?!, COST E 19 working paper, 2001.

H. Burgess and G. Burgess, Constructive confrontation: a transformative approach to intractable conflicts. Mediation quarterly, pp.305-322, 1996.

G. Buttoud, Principles of participatory processes in public decision making, Regional Forest Programmes: A Participatory Approachto Support Forest Based Regional Development. EFI Proceedings, pp.11-28, 1999.
URL : https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01191020

G. Buttoud, Negotiation methods to support participatory forestry planning, Regional Forest Programmes: A Participatory Approach to Support Forest Based Regional Development. EFI Proceedings, pp.29-45, 1999.
URL : https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01191021

G. Buttoud and I. Yunusova, A ???mixed model??? for the formulation of a multipurpose mountain forest policy., Forest Policy and Economics, vol.4, issue.2, pp.149-160, 2002.
DOI : 10.1016/S1389-9341(02)00014-X

D. Brazer and R. Keller, 2006 -A Conceptual Framework for Multiple Stakeholder Educational Decision Making, International Journal of Education Policy and Leadership, vol.1, issue.3

N. N. Eckley, Designing effective assessments: the role of participation, science and governance, and focus. Discussion paper, Research and Assessment Systems for Sustainability ProgrammeDependable dynamism: lessons for designing scientific assessment processes in consensus negotiations, Global Environmental Change, vol.12, pp.1-3, 2001.

R. Fiorino, D. , and J. , Citizen Participation and Environmental Risk: A Survey of Institutional Mechanisms, Science, Technology & Human Values, vol.15, issue.2, pp.226-243
DOI : 10.1177/016224399001500204

T. J. Foy, M. J. Pitcher, and C. B. Willis, Participatory Development of forest policy: some practical lessons from recent South African Experience, Commonwealth Forestry Review, vol.77, issue.2, pp.100-106, 1998.

C. Gamborg and J. Bo-larsen, Towards more sustainable forestry ? The ethics of closeto ? nature forestry, European Forests and Beyond, and ethical discourse, pp.55-65, 2005.

M. Gramberger, 2001 -Citizens as Partners: Information, Consultation and Public Participation in Policy Making

M. Krott, Forest Policy analysis. European Forest Institute, 2005.

P. Perhac and M. , Comparative Risk Assessment: Where Does the Public Fit In?, Science, Technology & Human Values, vol.23, issue.2, pp.221-241, 1998.
DOI : 10.1177/016224399802300204

O. Saastamoinen, Multiple ethics for multidimensional sustainability in forestry ? in Erkkila et al. (eds) European Forests and Beyond, and Ethical Discourse, pp.55-65, 2005.

M. Shannon, -The use of participatory approaches, methods and techniques in the elaboration on Integrated Management Plans The formulation of integrated management plans (IMPs) for mountain forests, Proceedings of the international research course, pp.119-135, 2002.
URL : https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01005215

T. Webler and S. Tuler, 2002 -Unlocking puzzle for public participation. Bulletin of science, technology & society, pp.179-189

J. Amdam, Mobilization, participation and partnership building in local development planning: Experience from local planning on women's conditions in six Norwegian communes, European Planning Studies, vol.61, issue.3, pp.305-332
DOI : 10.1080/09654319508720309

. J. Amdam, 2000 -Confidence Building in Local Planning and Development. Some experience from Norway, European Planning Studies, vol.8, issue.5

J. Amdam, 2003 -Structure and strategy for regional learning and innovation ? challenges for regional planning, European Planning Studies, vol.11, issue.6

A. Bandura and P. Beers, Computer support for knowledge construction in collaborative learning environments, Computers in Human Behaviour, pp.623-643, 1977.

B. T. Bormann, P. G. Cunningham, M. H. Brookes, V. W. Manning, and M. W. Collopy, 1993 - Adaptive ecosystem management in the Pacific Northwest

G. Buttoud, Developing partnership between forestry agencies and stakeholders: the mixed model as a strategic planning tool. in: Partnership in Forestry, Seminar Proceedings of Joint FAO/ECE/ILO Committee on Forest Policy, pp.3-6, 2002.

S. Clegg, The theory of power and organization, 1979.

R. Dahl, 1957 -The concept of power, Political power: a reader in theory and research, p.80

R. Dahl, 1961 ? Who governs? Democracy and power in an American city

S. Daniels, Collaborative learning, an approach for designing community discussions. Presentation at the, Public Policy Education Conference, 2000.

S. Daniels and G. Walker, Collaborative learning: Improving public deliberation in ecosystem-based management, Environmental Impact Assessment Review, vol.16, issue.2, pp.71-102, 1996.
DOI : 10.1016/0195-9255(96)00003-0

B. Delali, 2003 -Whose involvement? -can hierarchical valuation scheme intercede for participatory methods for evaluating secondary forest resource use?, Forest Policy and Economics, issue.5, pp.265-283

H. Dreifus, Being and power: Heidegger and Foucault, International Journal of Philosophical Studies, vol.4, issue.1, pp.1-16, 1996.
DOI : 10.1080/09672559608570822

Y. Engeström, 1987 -Learning by expanding: An activity theoretical approach to developmental research, Orienta-Konsultit Oy

Y. Engeström, Innovative learning in work teams: Analyzing cycles of knowledge creation in practice, Perspectives on activity theory, pp.377-404, 1999.
DOI : 10.1017/CBO9780511812774.025

A. Etzioni, 1997 ? Deliberations, culture wars and moral dialogues. The good society, APEGS Journal, vol.7, issue.1, pp.34-38

A. Etzioni, Towards a new socio-economic paradigm. Socio-economic review, pp.105-118, 2003.

J. Friedman, Planning in the public domain: from knowledge to action, 1987.

C. Gamborg and J. Bo-larsen, Towards more sustainable forestry ? The ethics of closeto ? nature forestry, European Forests and Beyond, and ethical discourse, pp.55-65, 2005.

D. Humphreys, 1996 ? Forest politics. The evolution of international cooperation

C. Ozawa, Recasting science. Consensual procedures in public policy making, 1991.

R. Ramirez, 1998 ? Participatory learning and approaches for managing pluralism, pp.49-92

O. Saastamoinen, Multiple ethics for multidimensional sustainability in forestry ? European Forests and Beyond, and ethical discourse, pp.55-65, 2005.

P. Sabatier and A. , An advocacy coalition framework of policy change and the role of policy-oriented learning therein, Policy Sciences, vol.16, issue.No. 1, pp.129-168, 1988.
DOI : 10.1007/BF00136406

P. R. Simons, 1991 -Constructive learning: the role of the learner. Paper presented at the NATO Advanced Research Workshop on the Design of Constructivist Learning Environments

H. Schanz, 1999 ? Social changes and forestry. in Pelkonen, P

G. Oesten and P. Piussi, Forestry in changing societies in Europe, Joensuu, vol.1, pp.59-82

M. Shannon, Moving from the limits and problems of rational planning toward a collaborative and participatory planning approach, Formulation and Implementation of National Forest Programmes. EFI Proceedings, pp.139-151, 1999.

M. Shannon, Understanding Collaboration as Deliberative Communication, Organisational Form and Emergent Institution, National Forest Programmes in a European Context, EFI Proceedings, pp.7-25, 2002.

M. Shannon, ? the Northwest Forest Plan as a learning process: a call for new institutions bringing science and politics Forest futures: science, politics and policy for the next century, 2003.

M. F. Shannon, G. Buttoud, and . Edit, -The use of participatory approaches, methods and techniques in the elaboration on Integrated Management Plans The formulation of integrated management plans (IMPs) for mountain forests, Proceedings of the international research course, pp.119-135, 2002.
URL : https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01005215

E. Wenger, 1999 -Communities of Practice. Learning, meaning and identity

D. Yankelovich, Coming to public judgement: making democracy work in a complex world, 1991.

R. Ashcraft, 1986 -Revolutionary Politics and Locke's Two Treatises of Government

G. Buttoud and I. Yunusova, A ???mixed model??? for the formulation of a multipurpose mountain forest policy., Forest Policy and Economics, vol.4, issue.2, pp.149-160, 2002.
DOI : 10.1016/S1389-9341(02)00014-X

R. Dahl, 1957 -The concept of power Political power: a reader in theory and research, p.80

R. Dahl, Who governs? Democracy and power in an American city, 1961.

;. A. Etzioni, Mixed scanning: a " third " approach to decision making. Public Administrative review 27, pp.385-392, 1967.

M. Foucault, 1980 -Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings, pp.1972-1977

A. Giddens, 1998 -The Third Way. The Renewal of Social Democracy

B. Kidd, The science of power, 1919.
DOI : 10.5962/bhl.title.31245

H. Lasswell and A. Kaplan, 1951 -Power and Society: A Framework for Political Inquiry, American Sociological Review, vol.16, issue.1, pp.118-119

C. Merriam, 1935 -Political Power: Its Composition and Incidence, The Canadian Journal of Economics and Political Science, vol.1, issue.2, pp.311-313

C. Ozawa and P. , Recasting Science: Consensual Procedures in Public Policy Making, 1991.

N. Roberts, Public Deliberation in an Age of Direct Citizen Participation, The American Review of Public Administration, vol.34, issue.4, pp.315-353
DOI : 10.1177/0275074004269288

M. Shannon, Understanding Collaboration as Deliberative Communication, Organisational Form and Emergent Institution, National Forest Programmes in a European Context, EFI Proceedings, pp.7-25, 2002.

J. Zanden, Pareto and Fascism Reconsidered*, American Journal of Economics and Sociology, vol.19, issue.4, p.399
DOI : 10.1111/j.1536-7150.1960.tb00407.x

J. Amdam, Mobilization, participation and partnership building in local development planning: Experience from local planning on women's conditions in six Norwegian communes, European Planning Studies, vol.61, issue.3, pp.305-332
DOI : 10.1080/09654319508720309

. J. Amdam, 2000 -Confidence Building in Local Planning and Development. Some experience from Norway, European Planning Studies, vol.8, issue.5

J. Amdam, 2003 -Structure and strategy for regional learning and innovation ? challenges for regional planning, European Planning Studies, issue.6, p.11

C. Argyris, 1977 -Double Loop Learning in Organizations, Harvard Business Review, vol.55, pp.9-10

C. Argyris, 1993 -On Organizational Learning

C. Argyris, and Schon D;A, 1978 -Organizational Learning: A Theory of Action Perspective

S. Arnstein, A Ladder Of Citizen Participation, Journal of the American Institute of Planners, vol.35, issue.4, pp.216-240, 1969.
DOI : 10.1080/01944366908977225

G. Buttoud and J. Samyn, Politique et planification forestiére; guide pour la formulation et l'évalution. Intercooperation, 1999.

G. Buttoud and I. Yunusova, A ???mixed model??? for the formulation of a multipurpose mountain forest policy., Forest Policy and Economics, vol.4, issue.2, pp.149-160, 2002.
DOI : 10.1016/S1389-9341(02)00014-X

R. Dahl, 1957 -The concept of power Political power: a reader in theory and research, p.80

R. Dahl, 1961 ? Who governs? Democracy and power in an American city

;. A. Etzioni, Mixed-Scanning: A "Third" Approach to Decision-Making, Public Administration Review, vol.27, issue.5, pp.385-392, 1967.
DOI : 10.2307/973394

A. Etzioni, Mixed Scanning Revisited, Public Administration Review, vol.46, issue.1, pp.8-14, 1986.
DOI : 10.2307/975437

. Etzioni, A, 1997 ? Deliberations, culture wars and moral dialogues. The good society, a PEGS journal, pp.34-38

. Etzioni, A Communitarian Note on Stakeholder Theory, Business Ethics Quarterly, vol.8, issue.4, pp.679-691
DOI : 10.2307/3857547

. Etzioni, Toward a new socio-economic paradigm. Socio-economic review, pp.105-118, 2003.

J. Friedmann, 1987 -Planning in the Public Domain: From Knowledge to Action

K. N. Lee, 1993 -Compass and Gyroscope. Integrating science and politics for the environment

C. E. Lindblom, The Science of "Muddling Through", Public Administration Review, vol.19, issue.2, pp.79-88
DOI : 10.2307/973677

C. Lindblom, The policy-making process, 1980.

C. Lindblom, Inquiry and change Yale, UK Kyrgyz Republic Government, 2004 -Concept of forestry sector development in Kyrgyz Republic. Intercooperation ? Kyrgyz State Forest Service, 1990.

. Kyrgyz-republic and . Government, 2006 -National Action Plan 2006-2010. State Agency on Environment Protection and Foretsry ? Intercooperation ? SDC

E. A. Parson and W. C. Clark, Sustainable Development as Social Learning: Theoretical Perspecitves and Practical Challenges for the Design of a Research Program. Pages 428-60 in, Barriers and Bridges to the Renewal of Ecosystems and Institutions, 1995.

V. Asselt, J. Mellors, and . Rijkens-klomp, 2001 -Building blocks for participation in Integrated assessment: a review of participatory methods

E. Baran and T. Jantunen, 2004 -Stakeholder consultation for Bayesian decision support systems in environmental management, Proceedings of the Regional Conference on Ecological and Environmental Modelling, pp.15-16, 2004.

R. Barbier, Quand le public prend ses distances avec la participation, Natures Sciences Soci??t??s, vol.13, issue.3, pp.258-265, 2005.
DOI : 10.1051/nss:2005040

URL : http://www.cairn.info/load_pdf.php?ID_ARTICLE=NSS_133_0258

J. Berry, Y. Poortinga, M. Seagall, and P. Dasen, 1992 -Cross-cultural Psychology: Research and applications

J. Clifford, 1988 -The predicament of culture

M. Crozier, Actors and systems: the politics of collective action, 1980.

J. Druzek and S. , Discursive democracy press: press, politics, and political science, 1990.

N. Duinker, 1998 -Public participation's promising progress: advances in forest decisionmaking in Canada, Commonwealth Forestry Review, vol.77, issue.2, pp.107-112

P. V. Ellefson, Forest resources policy: process, participants and programmes, 1992.

P. Glueck, 1998 -Formulation and implementation of National Forest Programmes. International Experiences. Theoretical Aspects, Proceedings of the International Seminar EFI Proceedings, 1998.

J. E. Force and K. L. Williams, 1989 -A Profile of national forest planning participants, Journal of forestry, pp.33-38

O. Hofstad, 2002 ? Stakeholder participation and democracy ? a structural-functionalist observation of forest politics in Norway and Africa, National Forest Programmes in a European Context, EFI Proceeding, pp.49-58

H. J. Cortner and M. Shannon, 1993 -Embedding Public Participation, Journal of Forestry, pp.14-16

W. Kicekrt, Autopoiesis and the science of (public) administration: essence, sense and nonsense. Organisation studies, pp.261-278, 1993.

T. Knopp and E. Caldbeck, The role of participatory democracy in forest management, Journal of Forestry, pp.13-18, 1990.

V. A. Sample, A framework for public participation in natural resource decision making, Journal of Forestry, pp.22-27, 1993.

B. Shindler and N. Neburka, Public participation in Forest Planning. 8 attributes of success, Journal of Forestry, vol.1, pp.17-19, 1997.

C. Daugbjerg and . Madrid, Designing Policy Change in Institutionalised Policy Networks Proceedings of the COST E-19 Seminar on " National forestry programmes: social and political context, pp.18-21, 2000.

K. Hanspeter, R. Koopmans, J. Duyvendak, and M. Giugni, 1992 -New social movements and political opportunities in Western Europe, European Journal of Political Research, vol.22, pp.219-244

G. Honadle, National forestry programmes: social and political context Communities and forest management in Western Europe. A regional profile of WG-CIFM. The Working group on community involvement in forest management, Conceptual Considerations for the 21 st Century. Proceedings of the COST E-19 Seminar on, p.148, 2000.

T. Knopp and E. Caldbeck, The role of participatory democracy in forest management, Journal of Forestry, pp.13-18, 1990.

J. Tanz and A. Howard, Meaningful public participation in the planning and management of publicly owned forests. The Forestry Chronicle, pp.125-130, 1991.

E. Sampson, The challenge of social change for psychology: Globalization and psychology's theory of the person., American Psychologist, vol.44, issue.6, pp.914-921
DOI : 10.1037/0003-066X.44.6.914

F. Schneider, Can incentive-oriented environmental policies in representative democracies be implemented? A public choice analysis Formulation and implementation of National Forest Programmes. International Experiences. Theoretical Aspects, Proceedings of the International Seminar EFI Proceedings, pp.18-20, 1998.

H. Cortner and J. , -Research agenda for designing administrative structures that ensure sustainability. Paper presented at the International Union of Forestry Research Organizations meeting in, 1995.

H. Hanninnen and P. Ollonqvist, -Institutional aspects as supporting and impeding factors of the process of Finnish National Forest Programme

M. Howlett, Policy learning and policy change: reconciling knowledge and interests in the policy process Formulation and implementation of National Forest Programmes. International Experiences. Theoretical Aspects, Proceedings of the International Seminar EFI Proceedings, pp.85-96, 1998.

D. Laat, M. Simons, and P. R. , Collective learning : theoretical perspectives and ways to support networked learning, Vocational training : European Journal, pp.13-34, 2002.

J. M. Levine, L. B. Resnick, and E. T. Higgins, Social Foundations of Cognition, Annual Review of Psychology, vol.44, issue.1, pp.585-612
DOI : 10.1146/annurev.ps.44.020193.003101

J. Liebowitz, Knowledge management: Handbook, 1999.
DOI : 10.1201/b12285

C. Lusthaus, M. Adrien, and P. Morgan, Integrating capacity development into project design and evaluation. Monitoring and evaluation working paper 5, p.25, 2000.

A. Mendes, 2002 -Financial and other economic instruments as supporting and impeding factors of national forest programmes, Discussion paper for Working Group 2, sessions of the COST Action E19 Seminar " Cross sectoral policy impacts on forests, pp.5-6, 2002.

L. C. Moll, J. Tapia, and K. P. Whitmore, Living Knowledge: the social distribution of cultural resources for thinking, Distributed Cognitions: psychological and educational considerations, pp.139-163, 1993.

L. B. Resnick, 1991 -Shared Cognition: thinking as social practice, Perspectives on Socially Shared Cognition, pp.1-20
DOI : 10.1037/10096-018

B. Shindler and K. Cheek, Integrating Citizens in Adaptive Management: A Propositional Analysis, Conservation Ecology, vol.3, issue.1, p.911, 1999.
DOI : 10.5751/ES-00112-030109

B. Shindler and J. Neburka, Public Participation in Forest Planning, Journal of Forestry, pp.17-19, 1997.

P. R. Simons, J. Van-der-linden, and T. Duffy, 2000 -New Learning: three ways to learn in a new balance, New Learning Kluwer Academc Publishers, pp.1-20

B. Sormin, 1999 ? Major developments and issues related to the promotion of national forest and land use in Indonesia, Formulation and implementation of National Forest Programmes. International Experiences

L. S. Vygotsky, V. Cole, S. John-steiner, E. Scribner, and . Souberman, 1978 -Mind in Society: the development of higher psychological processes

J. Walton, Strategic Human Resource Development, 1999.

R. Wegerif and N. Mercer, From social interaction to individual reasoning: an empirical investigation of a possible socio-cultural model of cognitive development, Learning and Instruction, vol.9, issue.6, pp.493-516
DOI : 10.1016/S0959-4752(99)00013-4

J. Wertsch, 1991 -A Sociocultural Approach to Socially Shared Cognition

C. Wildemeersch, Janssesns, 2002 ? Social learning and urban forestry planning: the case of urban forest planning in Flanders

L. Wollenberg, D. Edmunds, and L. Buck, Draft version, Feb. 28,) 2000 -Anticipating change: scenarios as a tool for adaptive forest management

S. Arnstein, A Ladder Of Citizen Participation, Journal of the American Institute of Planners, vol.35, issue.4, pp.216-240, 1969.
DOI : 10.1080/01944366908977225

M. Barnet and R. Duvall, Power in global governance, 2005.

J. Buchanan and G. Tullock, 1962 ? The Calculus of Consent: logical foundations of constitutional democracy. The University of

M. Buchy and S. Hoverman, Understanding public participation in forest planning: a review, Forest Policy and Economics, vol.1, issue.1, pp.15-22, 2000.
DOI : 10.1016/S1389-9341(00)00006-X

G. Buttoud and I. Yunusova, A ???mixed model??? for the formulation of a multipurpose mountain forest policy., Forest Policy and Economics, vol.4, issue.2, pp.149-160, 2002.
DOI : 10.1016/S1389-9341(02)00014-X

R. Chambers, 1997 -Whose reality counts? Putting the last first. Intermediate technology

S. Clegg, The theory of power and organization, 1979.

J. Cohen, Procedure and substance in deliberative democracy Democracy and difference: contesting the boundaries of the political, pp.95-109, 1996.

J. Cohen, 1997 -Deliberation and Democratic Legitimacy, Deliberative Democracy: Essays on Reason and Politics

G. Davis, Consultation, public participation and the integration of multiple interests into policy making

R. Dahl, 1957 -The concept of power, Political power: a reader in theory and research, p.80

R. Dahl, Who governs? Democracy and power in an American city, 1961.

J. Dryzek, Discursive democracy: politics, policy and political science, 1990.

J. Dryzek, Policy Analysis and Planning, 1993.
DOI : 10.1215/9780822381815-010

A. Etzioni, 1997 ? Deliberations, culture wars and moral dialogues. The good society, A PEGS Journal, vol.7, issue.1, pp.34-38

D. J. Fiorino, 1990 -Citizen Participation and Environmental Risk: A Survey of Institutional Mechanisms, Science, Technology and Human Values, pp.226-243

J. Fishkin, 1991 -Democracy and Deliberation

S. Fiske and E. Depret, Control, Interdependence and Power: Understanding Social Cognition in Its Social Context, European Review of Social Psychology, vol.8, issue.1, pp.31-61
DOI : 10.1037/h0040934

B. Flyvbjerg, Habermas and Foucault: thinkers for civil society, British Journal of Sociology, vol.49, issue.2, pp.208-233, 1998.
DOI : 10.2139/ssrn.2237923

J. Forester, Planning in the Face of Power, Journal of the American Planning Association, vol.74, issue.4, pp.67-80, 1982.
DOI : 10.1080/01944368208976167

M. Foucault, Discipline and Punish, 1977.
DOI : 10.1215/9780822390169-018

M. Foucault, 1981 -Omnes et singulatim: towards a criticism of 'political reason The Tanner Lectures on Human Values, pp.223-54

M. Foucault, 1982a -The Subject and the Power, pp.208-234

R. Gauld, 1996 ? Power, reform and performance in contemporary public policy-making: a discussion. in Public and social administration working paper series, 1996.

J. Gaventa, ? Power and powerlessness. Quiescence and rebellion in an Appalachian Valley. Chapter 1: Power and participation, pp.1-32, 1980.

R. Germain, D. Floyd, and S. Stehman, Public perceptions of the USDA Forest Service public participation process, Forest Policy and Economics, vol.3, issue.3-4, pp.113-124, 2001.
DOI : 10.1016/S1389-9341(01)00065-X

L. Guinier, The Tyranny of the Majority : Fundamental Fairness in Representative Democracy The Free Press 1982 -The Entwinement of Myth and Enlightenment: Rereading Dialectic of Enlightenment, p.27, 1994.

J. Habermas, 1982 -A Reply to my Critics, Habermas: Critical Debates, p.262

J. Habermas, 1987 ? The theory of Communicative Action, Lifeworld and Systems: the critics of functionalists reason, pp.257-282

J. Habermas, Moral Consciousness and Communicative Action, 1990.

J. Habermas, 1994 -Three Normative Models of Democracy, Constellation, p.8

J. Habermas, 1996 -Between Facts and Norms Contributions to a Discourse Theory of Law and Democracy

P. Hall, Policy Paradigms, Social Learning, and the State: The Case of Economic Policymaking in Britain, Comparative Politics, vol.25, issue.3, pp.275-296, 1993.
DOI : 10.2307/422246

P. Healey, Planning through debate: the communicative turn in planning theory, Town Planning Review, vol.63, issue.2, pp.143-162
DOI : 10.3828/tpr.63.2.422x602303814821

P. Healey, The argumentative turn in planning theory and its implication for spatial strategy formation Are local strategies possible?, 1995.

O. Hofstaad, 2002 -Stakeholder participation and democracy ? a structural-functionalist observation of forest policies in Norway and Africa, (eds) National Forest Programmes in a European Context, EFI Proceedings, pp.49-58

D. B. Jouvenel, On power: the natural history of its growth, 1945.

B. Kidd, The science of power, 1919.
DOI : 10.5962/bhl.title.31245

K. H. Kobach and A. Kaplan, 1993 -The Referendum: Direct Democracy in Switzerland 1951 -Power and Society: A Framework for Political Inquiry, American Sociological Review, vol.16, issue.1, pp.118-119

P. Levine, Getting Practical about Deliberative Democracy. in: Rowman & Littlefield Edit. The New Progress Era: Toward a Fair and Deliberative Democracy www, 2002.

L. Leskinen, Purposes and challenges of public participation in regional and local forestry in Finland, Forest Policy and Economics, vol.6, issue.6, pp.605-618, 2004.
DOI : 10.1016/S1389-9341(03)00009-1

S. Lukes, Power: a radical view, 1974.

J. Mansbridge, A deliberative theory of interest trasnformation In The politics of interests: interest groups transformed, pp.32-57, 1992.

T. Mendelberg, The deliberative citizen: theory and evidence. Political decision making, deliberation and participation, pp.151-193, 2002.

C. Merriam, 1935 -Political Power: Its Composition and Incidence, The Canadian Journal of Economics and Political Science, vol.1, issue.2, pp.311-313

R. Perhac and M. , Defining risk: Normative considerations, Human and Ecological Risk Assessment: An International Journal, vol.21, issue.3, pp.381-392, 1996.
DOI : 10.1080/10807039609383615

N. Roberts, Public Deliberation in an Age of Direct Citizen Participation, The American Review of Public Administration, vol.34, issue.4, pp.315-353, 2004.
DOI : 10.1177/0275074004269288

W. R. Sewell and . S. Phillips, 1979 -Models for the Evaluation of Public Participation Programs, Natural Resources Journal, vol.19, pp.337-358

J. Sorg, P. Venglovsky, B. , I. Schmidt, and K. ?. Orech-les, Biodiversity and sustainable management of Kyrgyzstan's walnut-fruit forest: development of new silvicultural approaches. European Tropical Forests Research Network News, pp.65-67, 2003.

S. Tuler and T. Webler, Process evaluation for discoursive deicion making in Environmental and risk policy, Human Ecological Review, vol.2, pp.62-74, 1995.

S. Tuler and T. Webler, Designing an analytic deliberative process for environmental health policy making in the US Nuclear Weapons complex. Risk: Health safety and environment, pp.65-87, 1999.

T. Webler and S. Tuler, 2002 -Unlocking puzzle for public participation. Bulletin of science, technology & society, pp.179-189

A. Wellstead, R. Stedman, and J. Parkins, Understanding the concept of representation within the context of local forest management decision making, Forest Policy and Economics, vol.5, issue.1, pp.1-11, 2003.
DOI : 10.1016/S1389-9341(02)00031-X

A. Barry, 1991 -Government in Foucault, Canadian Journal of Philosophy, vol.21, issue.4, pp.421-440

É. Balibar, 1992 -Foucault and Marx: The question of nominalism, Michel Foucault philosopher, pp.38-56

C. Buckle and S. Thomas-buckle, Placing environmental mediation in context: Lessons from ???failed??? mediations, Environmental Impact Assessment Review, vol.6, issue.1, pp.55-70, 1986.
DOI : 10.1016/0195-9255(86)90040-5

H. Burgess and G. Burgess, 1996 -Constructive confrontation: a transformative approach to intractable conflicts, Mediation Quarterly, vol.134, pp.305-322

B. Cruikshank, 1999 -The Will to Empower. Democratic Citizens and Other Subjects

S. E. Daniels and G. B. Walker, Collaborative learning: Improving public deliberation in ecosystem-based management, Environmental Impact Assessment Review, vol.16, issue.2, pp.71-102
DOI : 10.1016/0195-9255(96)00003-0

M. Dean, 1994 -Critical and Effective Histories. Foucault's Methods and Historical Sociology, 1982.
DOI : 10.4324/9780203414217

H. Dreyfus and P. Rabinow, What is maturity, Foucault : a Critical Reader, 1986.

S. Selin and D. Chavez, Developing a collaborative model for environmental planning and management, Environmental Management, vol.Winter, issue.1, pp.189-195
DOI : 10.1007/BF02471990

J. Sirmon, W. E. Shands, and C. Liggett, 1993 -Communities of interests and open decision making, Journal of Forestry, vol.91, issue.7, pp.17-21

B. Solberg, S. Miinia, and . Edits, Conflict management and public participation in land management, EFI Proceedings, vol.14, 1997.